Skip to main content

Less Header in Football for Health Cause, Is it Possible?



The recommendation to lessen the number of heading in football games to reduce the risk of dementia appears to be easier said than done.

Concerns about the impact of headers in football have grown since the departure of former England internationals from the 1966 World Cup squad, Nobby Stiles, in 2020. He was diagnosed with dementia, which was linked to the repeated headings. Stiles' teammates in the Three Lions squad, including Martin Peters, Ray Wilson, the former Republic of Ireland manager, Jack Charlton, and his younger brother, Bobby Charlton, who died in October 2023, reportedly shared the same neurodegenerative condition.

The Potential Risk

Such tendency has been supported by the date from further study and research. During an interview with Sky Sports, Dr. Willie Stewart, Honorary Clinical Associate Professor at the University of Glasgow and the study's lead expert, expressed his concern. He claimed that footballers were 3.5 times more likely than the general population to die from brain disease, and that replacing the modern ball with a faster-moving one, as compared to the ball in 1976, could arguably make it worse.

The data appears to corroborate the findings of a 2019 PFA (Professional Football Association) charity-funded study on FIELD (Football's Influence on Lifelong Health and Dementia risk), which found that footballers had a 3.5 times higher death rate from neurodegenerative conditions than the general population.

As a result, the less heading in football has been proposed. Dr. Stewart believed that an immediate change was required at all levels, including modifying training by reducing any unnecessary heading, reducing all of it in youth football, and conducting additional research into any head injuries in the professional game.  Based on the evidence available, PFA chairman Ben Purkiss has urged the football authorities to intervene.

Possible or Not?

The question of whether it is possible to reduce the heading in the match, whether for scoring goals, providing assists, or clearing, remains unanswered. It is unclear when any football governing bodies will impose a new regulation for it. Surprisingly, there has already been interesting development at the top level.

The average number of headers per game in the major European leagues is higher in the English Premier League and German Bundesliga than in the Italian Serie A, French Ligue 1 and Spanish La Liga. However, the numbers appear to be decreasing in all of the top flights except La Liga.

This shift may be related to the tactical trend in Spain's top flight, where more teams are using longer passes and relying more on physical duels rather than technical skills and creativity. These are diametrically opposed to the nature of Latin football.

The success of Atletico Madrid under Diego Simeone in the past decade by winning two league titles (2014 and 2021) , two UEFA Champions League runners-up (2014 and 2016) as well as two Europa League and UEFA Super Cup trophies (2012 and 2018) might be inspiring more teams to follow their footsteps. Their playing style and even formations have grown in popularity, particularly among mid and lower table teams lacking marquee signings. Athletic Bilbao, Valencia, Villarreal and Getafe are some of the examples.  

In summary, there may have been some awareness in modern football regarding the brain injury issue as a long term impact on headings, at least at the European major leagues, which could lead to a gradual adjustment. Nevertheless, an official game rule to reduce header is still necessary for the sake of the players' health. After all, with less heading on the pitch, players and teams will be forced to be more creative and improve their technical abilities rather than emphasising physical duels.

Comments

Popular posts from this blog

Who is Emiliano Martinez’s Ideal Replacement in Argentina

  Argentina are bound to decide Emiliano Martinez’s ideal replacement for the two fixtures in the 2026 FIFA World Cup qualifiers this week. Emiliano Martinez made headlines again with his quirk controversy in last month’s games at the World Cup qualifiers. He reportedly hit the journalist after Argentina ’s loss to Colombia, leading to his two-game suspension. Consequently, he will not be available for these coming matches versus Venezuela and Bolivia. The Aston Villa shotstopper has cemented his place as the number one goalie in Albiceleste after helping them win Copa America 2021. He even went on winning the FIFA Best Goalkeeper awards in 2022 following his superb form in the Qatar 2022 FIFA World Cup. Unfortunately, he is also known for his controversial demeanour on the pitch, from his antics in the penalty shootout to the World Cup victory celebration. Martinez’s quirks were finally brought to justice, resulting in his suspension. Such has left Lionel Scaloni in a limited ch

The Best Balkan Boss in the European Elite Sides

  Several Balkan managers have been able to thrive at the European elite clubs. Balkan managers seem to be overlooked today. There have been very few of them who manage to thrive at the top level.  Recently, AS Roma has appointed Ivan Juric to replace Daniel de Rossi. The Croatian boss is a surprising name since he has yet to win any silverware. However, Juric’s stint with Hellas Verona and Torino didn't go unnoticed. Yet, taking charge of the midtable sides is entirely different from being at the helm of an elite team as Roma. Giallorossi is keen on returning to the Champions League, something that even the Special One, Jose Mourinho, could not achieve, despite winning the UEFA Conference League, their first continental trophy, in 2021.  Unfortunately, Roma’s campaign in Europe has already been dented by a shocking loss to Sweden’s Elfsborg in the Europa League this week. Juric might not be under pressure yet, but the former Crotone boss needs to turn things around before be

The non-traditional Elite Italian Teams in the Continental Finals

  Some non-elite Italian teams did reach the finals in European competitions before Atalanta and Fiorentina. The Italian clubs are on the headline again as they advance to the finals in European competitions as Atalanta and Fiorentina advance to the Europa League and Conference League finals, respectively. This is La Dea’s first ever continental final, while La Viola repeats their last season’s success. Such results lead to extra spots in the Champions League next season, which will use the new format. Italy is likely to have nine teams in the continental competitions. However, it does not create as much hype as last season, when Milan reached the semifinals of the Champions League, AS Roma advanced to the Europa League final, and Fiorentina advanced to the Conference League. The absence of traditional elite sides such as Juventus, Inter, AC Milan, or AS Roma in the summit might be the reason. Yet, it could be a sign of the silent rise of Italian football, just like in the old days. Ba