Skip to main content

Why South American Clubs are no longer a threat in the FIFA Club World Cup

 


The South American clubs are no longer the favourite to end UEFA’s domination in the FIFA Club World Cup.

The 2025 FIFA Club World Cup is set to begin at the end of this week. This expanded edition is expected to bring more competitive games and rekindle heated rivalries at the latter stage between UEFA and CONMEBOL sides. However, the latter reason seems rather out of reach considering the decline of the South American teams.

Their dipped performance in the tournament, which was once known in a one-off showdown between the UCL and Copa Libertadores champions, has been quite distressing. The last time CONMEBOL lifted the trophy was in 2012 when Corinthians snatched a scrappy 1-0 victory over Chelsea under Tite. Since then, Copa Libertadores champions have not always reached the final in the competition. In fact, in the past five editions, only three of them advanced to the summit.

No wonder that many have doubts they could win again, including in this year’s edition when CONMEBOL are represented by six teams. They are just half of the UEFA teams, which are likely to dominate again, probably from the last four.

Will Palmeiras, Flamengo, Fluminense, and Botafogo, plus River Plate and Boca Juniors, stand no chance to even progress further, or will they bounce back this time? None can tell, but their quality really raises the eyebrows compared to the European sides, and such appear to be justified by the reasons below.

The Big Gap with Europe

The most obvious one would be the big gap between two regions in terms of almost everything. In the football world, the gap mainly stems from the infrastructure, coaching and tactical development.

South Americans may boast of their talents, but when it comes to the clubs’ facilities, Europe is simply better. They have a better system and more modern infrastructure with more tech support to improve players’ performance as well as the teams. The players’ strengths and weaknesses plus potential injuries can be detected almost instantly with the assistance of various apps.

In terms of coaching and tactical development, Europe is certainly thriving. They have better sources and a deeper pool of talents in managerial positions. European teams have been ahead of their contenders with updated coaching, which can balance between developing technical and physical aspects. Such has been applied to the younger players as well.

In South America, technical qualities are seemingly still prioritised over the physical aspects. The former Boca Juniors goalkeeper, Carlos Montoya, appears to agree on this, which has been creating quite a setback. Such a mindset has been going on for years, and the change has only been initiated recently.

Their Young Talents' Premature Move to Europe

Another crucial factor which leads to a big gap between South American and European teams is the young talents paradox. The CONMEBOL sides, especially Brazil, Argentina and Uruguay, have been well-known for being the home of great football talents. In the past, they were nurtured by the local clubs before eventually spreading their wings to the other continent when they were mature enough. They most likely made a big move to Europe in their early 20s.

Today, the European giants have started their hunt for Latin America's young stars without waiting for them to shine in major youth competitions like the FIFA U20 World Cup. They roam to their wilderness and look to sign the raw talents to be exported before they even reach the age of 20.

The likes of Vinicius Jr, Rodrygo, Endrick, Vitor Roque and lastly, Estevao from Brazil and Argentina’s Emiliano Martinez, Claudio Echeverri, even Lionel Messi himself and most recently Franco Mastantuono have already departed to Europe before even winning prestigious trophies with their first local sides.

Such a trend is likely to continue and would definitely cost South American teams' performance when facing off against the European giants. Thus, despite their higher enthusiasm to compete the FIFA Club World Cup, they do not likely stand a chance to even reach the summit.

So, unless the European teams were willing to let them happen by fielding more players from the reserved teams and ‘embracing defeat’ soon so that they head to the exit earlier and return home sooner for resting their players, the South Americans will still be going home empty-handed at the end of the tournament.


Comments

Popular posts from this blog

The Best Football Films based on true Football Stories

  Football films based on true events are not as common as we might hope, but the few that exist certainly stand out as some of the best. Unlike American football or basketball films, football (or soccer, as it's called in the U.S.) hasn't gained the same level of popularity or production in Hollywood. That’s understandable, given the sport’s limited appeal in the U.S. historically. However, with the country set to co-host the expanded 48-team FIFA World Cup next year, more football films should be produced to build the hype and capture the spirit of the world’s biggest sporting event. Football movies have the unique ability to explore stories on and off the pitch — from a fan's perspective to tales centred around players, managers, or even lesser-known supporting characters. The following list focuses solely on those based on true events, highlighting the personal conflicts, dressing room dynamics, and emotional journeys that define real football legends. As we enjoy...

The Most Daring Journeyman Managers in History

  Not many gaffers opt to roam around the world to become journeyman managers in their careers and gain fair success.  Being a football manager, just like any other profession, needs a challenge to push the limit in their career, be it for the silverware, more noble missions like developing football in the remote countries, or simply for an adventure. It is quite rare to find one recently and thrive, especially at the top level.  One of the few such figures is probably Jorge Jesus. The Portuguese boss has currently signed for the post in Saudi Pro League side Al Nassr. It would be a challenge as well as an honour for him to lead Cristiano Ronaldo, something that he never had during his stints in Europe. Jesus mainly spent his career in his home soil and Turkey before venturing to South America and winning the prestigious title, Copa Libertadores 2019, with Flamengo. He is one of the few European gaffers who managed to do so. However, his experience in three contine...

Top Barcelona Stars signed from Espanyol

  More than 40 players were snatched by Barcelona from their city rival, Espanyol, for their first team, but only a few eventually thrived. Barcelona and RC Espanyol have been rivals for years, but it does not stop both sides from swapping players. Blaugrana did release more of their stars to their fellow Catalan side, but not exactly the opposite. Former Danish international Martin Braithwaite was the last one to play regularly for Espanyol in the 2022/23 season. This season, however, Hans Flick’s side does the opposite by signing Espanyol’s brightest talent last season, Joan Garcia. He was La Liga’s best shot stopper last season despite only helping his team finish at the lower table. In fact, Garcia is seemingly prepared to take up the number one spot from the club’s captain, Marc Ter Stegen. The German goalie has fallen out of favour under Hans Flick since his attitude ahead of the second leg of the UCL semifinal against Inter Milan last season. Should Garcia be able to p...